Vegans miss the  larger point
Vegans miss the larger point
Vegans miss the larger point

Vegans love to buy things. We are surrounded by things we can’t enjoy—food, entertainment, clothing. When we find animal-free shoes, purses, snacks and cookbooks we snatch them up with reckless abandon. If a restaurant with vegan options pops up, we’ll line up out the door. When two vegans meet, their conversations inevitably focus on what stores and eateries they frequent. 

In the mad dash to fill our lives with alternatives to animal industries, vegans tend to miss the greater point of a lifestyle dedicated to making the world a better place.

Ian Paxson is a vegan and anarchist activist trying to find a balance between anti-capitalism and veganism.  

“Initially I became vegan because I believed that consumer choices were a meaningful and effective means of challenging industries that exploit animals,” Paxson said. “However, now I maintain a vegan lifestyle because it makes me feel better about the way I interact with the world around me, even though I recognize that it has virtually zero efficacy.”

Paxson has been vegan for five years, though he recently ate meat. After three weeks, Paxson returned to a plant-based diet.

“I don't believe that consumer boycotts are efficacious by any means and that they are valid only in so far as they make you feel better about yourself and what you are putting into your body,” he said.

“Even now, while I maintain a vegan lifestyle, I go back and forth on whether or not I call myself vegan. Vegan is a capitalist consumer identity. I'm not a capitalist and by extension, don't identify myself by what I do and do not purchase.”

Vegan alternatives are not inherently better for animals or the planet. Pleather and faux fur—staples of vegan fashion—are petroleum-based products. The environmental devastation caused by petroleum—climate change, oil spills, toxic water, acid rain, genetic mutations—are well known and vast. While many vegans will tout the environmental values of hybrid cars, bicycling, reusable shopping bags and eliminating demand for factory farms, the analysis rarely curbs the demand for couture. Sure, cows were not slaughtered for our beloved shoes, coats and belts. However, plenty of other animals were destroyed when their habitats were ransacked, covered in oil, poisoned and abandoned.

If the world as we know it were to go vegan, the dietary shift would not save animals or preserve land. Many of the plant-based products that vegans rely on come from subsidiaries of the largest food corporations. General Mills, Kraft, Heinz and ConAgra—big hands in animal industries—are the purveyors of some of the most popular soymilk, tofu, prepared food and meat substitute brands. (http://naturalsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/organiccompanieschart.png)

Industrial agriculture is no friend of the planet, nor does it preserve animal life. Soy (http://www.euractiv.com/cap/growing-demand-soybeans-threatens-amazon-rai...), a staple source of protein in many vegan diets, is responsible for massive deforestation in the Amazon rainforest. Perhaps community- or family-owned organic farms could reduce the environmental impact of our food choices. However, generating food supply that still allows for people to purchase food in grocery stores on demand with abundant selection with which the privileged vegan is accustomed to would require enormous expansion of current farming industry.

“I would even argue that industrialized veganism centered around wheat and soy production is worse for non-domesticated animals and the planet than an intelligently executed gatherer-hunter way of life,” said Paxson, who juggles this issue frequently.

While some opt for plant-based diets for health purposes alone, most vegans make the transition because they oppose the treatment of animals for the production of clothing and food. Animals are treated like commodities rather than living beings. They are forced to live torturous lives and are slaughtered cruelly. Ecosystems suffer from the massive demand for fuel, water and feed. What vegans must recognize is that the brutal treatment of animals and the planet is not a unique feature of food production, but an issue endemic to capitalism.

In capitalism, sentient beings get reduced to resources and products. This happens to humans, animals and ecosystems alike. A critique based solely on one dimension of this complex system dodges the greater issue.

In Paxson’s view, veganism is an act done for individuals.

“It is crucial to remember that it is never enough nor are an individual’s purchasing habits indicative of their ideological values,” he said. “It's also important to recognize the privilege inherent in being able to make those purchasing decisions.”

Capitalism is not an institution that can be changed internally. Boycotts and ethical consumerism shift money from one sector to another, still fueling the dominant system. They feed into the concept that those with privilege can maintain their access to goods and services on demand without ethical compromise.

Part of living on the privileged end of a capitalist society is choice. We have to decide how to live, knowing well that we are fueling a system that is destroying others. We do the best we can to impact others as little as possible. However, opting out of certain practices is not enough. To truly make a difference for animals - people and the planet - we must also work to dismantle the institutions that mandate suffering to ensure profit.

Categories: 

About author

Zoe Williams's picture

Zoë Williams is a Street Medic, artist, writer and anti-oppression organizer.

Daria's picture
Daria (not verified) Fri, 01/27/2012 - 14:19

You go Zoe!

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous (not verified) Wed, 11/20/2013 - 19:25

I love the site and stand by it.It's a meaningful website to learn something useful which i want to know .Hope for your next update.Vegan alternatives are not inherently better for animals or the planet. Pleather and faux fur—staples of vegan fashion—are petroleum-based products. The environmental devastation caused by petroleum—climate change, oil spills, toxic water, acid rain, genetic mutations—are well known and vast. While many vegans will tout the environmental values of hybrid cars, bicycling, reusable shopping bags and eliminating demand for factory farms, the analysis rarely curbs the demand for couture. Thanks for your information.Things are very open and intensely clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very beneficial. Appreciate your sharing.
Cheap American Idol Season 11 DVD|NCIS Season 11 DVD |The Closer Season 7 DVD | The Closer Seasons 1-7 slae

Boo's picture
Boo (not verified) Fri, 01/27/2012 - 15:20

Good luck hunting and gathering, hahaha!

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2014 - 01:13

I am also a 100% vegan and I do respect everyone's opinion. Thanks for this article. -buy vine likes
buysocialnow.com

Liliana's picture
Liliana (not verified) Sat, 01/28/2012 - 13:01

Look, I get your point, mostly, but soy in the amazon doesn't go to vegans/vegetarians. We are not large enough a comunity to credit for all of it, Most of it goes to cattle.
I know other options, like faux leather and fur are terrible for the enviroment, yeah, but you can't deny the terrible impact fur farms have in it too.
A veganlifestyle is cheap. There's not going around that. Meat, eggs and dairy are all expensive products when compared to the vegan organic alternatives.
Soy is not something inherent to it either (while an important part of it for many, is not necessary in any way).
I'm not saying a vegan lifestyle has no impact in the enviroment, nor than there is no privilege to the knowledge that animals aren't ours and live for their own reasons.
But a non-vegan lifestyle is more toxic in every way, and there's no way anyone can ignore that.

sabelmouse's picture
sabelmouse (not verified) Fri, 12/21/2012 - 09:03

actually most soy is grown for vegetable oils used in all sorts of food and sold as cooking oils/margarine, the leftover mush goes to animals.

Liliana's picture
Liliana (not verified) Sat, 01/28/2012 - 13:01

Look, I get your point, mostly, but soy in the amazon doesn't go to vegans/vegetarians. We are not large enough a comunity to credit for all of it, Most of it goes to cattle.
I know other options, like faux leather and fur are terrible for the enviroment, yeah, but you can't deny the terrible impact fur farms have in it too.
A veganlifestyle is cheap. There's not going around that. Meat, eggs and dairy are all expensive products when compared to the vegan organic alternatives.
Soy is not something inherent to it either (while an important part of it for many, is not necessary in any way).
I'm not saying a vegan lifestyle has no impact in the enviroment, nor than there is no privilege to the knowledge that animals aren't ours and live for their own reasons.
But a non-vegan lifestyle is more toxic in every way, and there's no way anyone can ignore that.

Jessica Parsons's picture
Jessica Parsons (not verified) Sun, 01/29/2012 - 01:42

I'm a vegan and have always been anti-consumer. I'm not offended, I just think the premise for the article as represented by the first paragraph is flawed based on most of the vegans I know. Paxson's point of view is admirable, but not as groundbreaking as implied.

http://minimalistmum.blogspot.com/

Lesero's picture
Lesero (not verified) Thu, 09/26/2013 - 05:58

W dzisiejszych porach adwokaci warszawscy pokonanie pracy wolno potwierdzać za zlecenie skomplikowane. Często zdarza się, ze mimo starań, nie jesteśmy w stanie znaleźć dla siebie zajęcia. Co sprawić w takiej pozycji? Może dobrym projektem będzie otwarcie lokalnego interesu? ORAZ takim jest z pewnością sklep online. adwokat warszawa Oczywiście realizacja takiego projektu, co istnieje całkiem jawne, nie obstaje do prostych zleceń. Możemy być pewn±, ze na swej drodze spotykamy wiele trudności. Ano ale pono lepsze owe niż oczekiwanie aż w końcu jakiś Pracodawca zlituje się nad nami oraz wieje nam profesje za najniższa krajową stawkę, ze która ciężko będzie nam się w ogóle obronić. W takich realiach po prostu musimy brać rzeczy w swoje ręce. A z drugiej paginy sklep internetowy nie wymaga od nas gigantycznych nakładów pieniędzy. Handel online wystawał się w przeszłych latach niestereotypowo wzięty. Zapewne wielu z nas monitoruje jak nieczęsto powstają nowiuteńkie sklepy adwokat warszawa internetowe. A tak naprawdę wszelki z nich może polegać na Kontrahentó

Rozetki's picture
Rozetki (not verified) Thu, 09/26/2013 - 06:09

Niezależnie od tak istotnych zalet podłóg epoksydowych sztukateria gipsowa i plafony rozeta , jak wzmiankowane powyżej nieścieralność oraz odporność chemiczna, ich dokładnym plusem są walory dekoracyjne. Dostępność żywicy w dużej palecie barwy przyklaskuje trwać posadzki o naprawdę fantazyjnym wyglądzie. – Zdatny wybór używanej podłogi pozwala nie tylko przegrupować właściwości wytrzymałościowe posadzki, ale także stylistykę pomieszczenia. Zatem tez posadzki tego typu wykorzystywane są z perfekcyjnym wynikiem w pomieszczeniach, w jakich odcinek ów jest sensacyjnie zupełny. Wolno wśród nich uhonorować salony sprzedaży mebli, furów, ale także właśnie dodane galerie handlowe – translato http://www.rozety.net.pl/ rów Siwak. Zarządcy nadmienionych przez eksperta celów powinny wiec specjalnie zaciekawić się posadzkami epoksydowymi, jak myślą o poprawie ich wize rozety.net runku natomiast stworzeniu wnętrza o interesującym wystroju. żeby wyróżnić się na tle rywalizacji, warto skupić się na rozpoznawalnym wykończeniu podłogi. Osiąg

Pages

Post new comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <a> <em> <strong> <b> <i> <u> <strike> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <table> <tbody> <tr> <td> <th> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <blockquote> <hr> <span> <br> <font> <sup> <sub> <div> <iframe> <object>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Remove empty newlines at beginning of text (leaves alone newlines embedded in body)

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Related Posts